Summary by: Roger Harris
Rob MacSweeney and Paul Marik debate whether the assessment of fluid responsiveness in the resuscitation of patients with shock a waste of time? Both Marik and MacSweeney agree that many of the traditional methods of assessing patients volume status are flawed and of no value. Marik goes on to argue that the only clinically meaningful outcome that we should measure in response to a fluid challenge is Stoke Volume. In at least 50% of patients there is no improvement in stroke volume and further treatment with fluid boluses will only likely cause harm. Marik goes on to argue that we must know where our patients are position on their Frank-Starling curve to predict whether they are fluid responsive and we can assess this with passive led raise.
See the Intensive Care Network Site for the Original Audio and Paul's Slides
Professor
Chief, Division of Emergency Critical Care
Director, Resuscitation and Acute Critical Care Unit
Stony Brook Medicine
Stony Brook, NY, USA
No conflicts of interest (coi).
- EMCrit 293 – The Jerk & Check, Functional Heuristics in Resuscitation Project (MotR) - March 3, 2021
- EMCrit 292 – IV T3 for Myxedema Coma, A Different Take with Eve Bloomgarden - February 23, 2021
- EMCrit 291 – For Frak's Sake, Ketamine is at least as Hemodynamically Stable as Etomidate! - February 9, 2021
[…] post SMACC Debate – Rob MacSweeney vs Paul Marik – Predicting Fluid Responsiveness is a Waste of Time appeared first on FOAM EM […]
[…] to Scott Weingart for editing this video – and letting us share it! See his post at EMCRIT, and the full post on this debate at Intensive Care Network for the original audio and […]
The most important point here is: we know PLR predicts fluid responsiveness but does that mean we keep giving fluids until the pt is no longer fluid responsive? What evidence is there for that because as they mention in the talk we are all fluid responsive but that doesn’t mean we all need to be infused.
[…] [SMACC podcast via EmCrit] Rob MacSweeney vs Paul Marik – Predicting Fluid Responsiveness is a Waste of Time […]
[…] Scott Weingart at EMCrit: Rob MacSweeney vs Paul Marik – Predicting Fluid Responsiveness is a Waste of Time […]
[…] [further listening] SMACC Debate – Rob MacSweeney vs Paul Marik – Predicting Fluid Responsiveness is a Waste of Time […]
[…] Scott Weingart at EMCrit: Rob MacSweeney vs Paul Marik – Predicting Fluid Responsiveness is a Waste of Time […]