The Right Ventricle gets no respect, but it is an easy source of clean kills in the ED. We haven't covered pulmonary hypertension and acute on chronic RV failure on the show yet–we need to fix that ASAP. So, let's hear from Susan Wilcox, MD on this critical topic. She just wrote an amazing review on the subject for Ann Emerg Med and as an EM Intensivist, she is the perfect person to talk on this topic.
Best Current Review for EM
- Ann Emerg Med 2015;66(6):619 by Susan R. Wilcox, MD
Other Articles to Check Out
Note: A good portion of these shownotes were contributed by Gregg Chesney, MD; ED Intensivist
Some Info
RV function determined by 3 P’s: preload, pump (RV contractility), and pipes (afterload)
RV is different than LV
- Thin walled, less muscular, more compliant, working against less afterload (PVR 1/10 of SVR)
- More dependent on volume loading than pressure to accomplish work of ventricle
- LV contracts in a wringing motion, RV contracts in a longitudinal up-and-down motion and compresses medially against septum
- RV doesn’t adapt well to acute changes in pressure/volume à dilates and becomes stiffer (takes 96 hrs to adapt)
Ventricular interdependence = LV and RV function are dependent on one another.
- LV preload = RV stroke volume, failing RV = decreased LV preload
- LV and RV share a muscular septum – contributes 20-40% of the work of RV contraction when LV contracts
- Dilated failing RV pushes IV septum into LV impairing LV filling/contractility and also impairing role of RV septum on RV contractility
RV Spiral Of Death
RV ischemia is the common final pathway that contributes to progressively worsening acute RV failure
Types of Pulmonary Hypertension
Causes of RV Failure can be broken into 4 Categories
ECHO: How to evaluate for RV failure at bedside
- Apical 4 chamber to evaluate relative size of RV to LV and to evaluate how RV “looks”
- If you are skilled, focus on lateral tricuspid annulus movement (TAPSE) 1.6
- McConnell’s sign may be indicative of acute RV failure with RV ischemia, not just seen in acute PE
- Parasternal short at level of mid-papillary to eval relationship between volumes and size of LV and RV and intraventricular septum – look for septal shift and the “D” Sign
- Plethoric IVC regardless of volume Status
- As RV dilates in chronic failure, there will be disruption of the tricuspid annulus leading to tricuspid regurg
Six step approach to management of acute RV failure
Step 1: Optimize volume status
- Lasix vs. fluids, use PSAX echo view to decide
- Err on the side of volume constriction, they are often overloaded unless the patient has a known source of volume loss
- Passive Leg Raising is probably a clever move before each small fluid bolus
- See: Diuretics in Normotensive Patients With Acute Pulmonary Embolism and Right Ventricular Dilatation (Circ J, 2013; 77: 2612–2618)
Step 2: Maintain coronary perfusion to limit RV ischemia (Keep MAPS up)
- Common final pathway in acute RV failure associated with pulm HTN is RV ischemia
- Also dilated RV = increased wall tension = decreased coronary perfusion
- Important to maintain SVR >> PVR to maintain R coronary perfusion pressure à Use pressors (norepi, vaso) not volume or chronotropes
- The pathophysiology of failure in acute right ventricular hypertension: hemodynamic and biochemical correlations. (Circulation. 1981 Jan;63(1):87-95)
- Treatment of shock in a canine model of pulmonary embolism. (Am Rev Respir Dis 1984, 130:870-874)
- Volume expansion versus norepinephrine in treatment of a low cardiac output complicating an acute increase in right ventricular afterload in dogs. (Anesthesiology 1984, 60:132-13)
Step 3: Enhance RV inotropy
- Dobutamine
- Milrinone
- Dobutamine and milrinone may need to be combined with vasoconstrictor (norepi or vaso) to counteract systemic hypotension
- Epinephrine
- (Levosimendan)
Step 4: Reduce RV afterload
- Inhaled pulmonary vasodilators (iNO, epoprostenol, iloprost)
- Dilates pulmonary vasculature in only ventilated areas – improves V/Q mismatch and oxygenation, decreases PVR
- Systemic pulmonary vasodilators (IV and po) – avoid in critically ill unless Group I already on the med, causes systemic hypotension and worsens oxygenation
- Oral PAH therapy – no role in critically ill
Step 5: Support Oxygenation and Ventilation
- Hypoxic vasoconstriction – normal physiologic response to unventilated lung segments, causes increased PVR
- Positive pressure ventilation – increased RV afterload and decreased RV preload may worsen RV failure
- Improved oxygenation with PPV may improve hypoxic vasoconstriction and decrease PVR, sum of effect of PPV in RV failure unpredictable
- Hypercapnea causes pulmonary vasoconstriction and increased PVR
- Low-tidal volume ventilation to keep plateau pressures low
- Intensive care med 2009 11 pts, PPV with plateau maintained
- acidosis and hypercapnea induced
Step 6: Treat the underlying cause
Rescue therapies
RVAD, VA ECMO
Gregg Chesney's algorithm for intubating patients with RV failure – Laryngoscope as a murder weapon
Intubating patients with Acute RV failure: Very high risk
- Intubation with RSI = Loss of native catecholamines leading to vasodilation and decreased venous return/preload leading to RV cardiac output to worsening RV ischemia to worsening RV failure
- Intubation with inadequate sedation leads to pain and agitation with airway manipulation leading to increased intrathoracic pressure and increased PVR to decreased venous return/preload leading to in RV cardiac output leading to worsening RV ischemia leading to worsening RV failure
- Strongly consider fentanyl, ketamine awake intubation
How to Do it
- PREPARE and GET HELP
- If urgent/semi-emergent intubation
- Place arterial line, obtain good vascular access
- Optimize volume status
- Consider awake intubation or awake fiberoptic intubation
- May help minimize hemodynamic perturbation
- Use topical lido + small dose of safe sedative
- Utilize video laryngoscopy
- Most experienced intubator
- If emergent intubation
- RSI with etomidate
- Anticipate hemodynamic collapse – use push-dose epinephrine, have norepinephrine or epinephrine drip already hanging
- I will “premedicate” pts with RV failure with push dose of 10-20mcg of epinephrine and 1-2U of vasopressin just prior to induction even if they aren’t hypotensive
- Re-evaluate volume status following intubation
CPR and Goals of Care
Pts unlikely to survive cardiac arrest when have RV failure, have ineffective CPR d/t poor pulmonary blood flow, (Hoeper, et al. (2002))
Pinsky's Thoughts on the RV
Unmasking right ventricular physiology The determinants of RV function are uniquely different from those determining LV function even though both ventricles have anatomically and functionally similar cardiac myocytes and the same beat frequency. First, RV filling occurs without any measurable change in RV distending pressure [1, 4]. Thus, preload is independent of RV EDV unless the RV is hypertrophied. At which point, central venous pressure increases in proportion to the increase in RV EDV [26]. Since venous return is the primary determinant of steady state cardiac output and since central venous pressure is the backpressure to venous return [27] acute RV overload must be associated with both increases in central venous pressure and cardiovascular compromise (acute cor pulmonale). Thus giving more intravenous volume challenges to patients with acute cor pulmonale (acute right heart failure) will only decrease cardiac output further. Second, that RV filling occurs below its unstressed volume has fundamental survival advantages for the host. Since spontaneous inspiration usually decreases intrathoracic pressure, central venous pressure will also decrease increasing the pressure gradient for venous return [27]. Thus, both RV filling and subsequently RV stroke volume will increase pulmonary blood flow at the same time alveolar gas is being refreshed by the tidal breath [28]. For this to provide maximal venous return, central venous pressure must not increase as RV EDV increases. Accordingly, the natural high RV diastolic compliance allows the increased venous return to be maximal. Furthermore, for this process to be effective, pulmonary vascular resistance must remain low. Under normal circumstances, with normal pulmonary vasculature and tidal volumes, pulmonary artery pressure does not increase more than a few millimeters of mercury as flow increases greatly [28]. Thus, the cardiopulmonary system is ideally adapted to maximize blood flow and gas exchange during spontaneous breathing and to increase them rapidly with exercise. Third, positive-pressure breathing by dissociating tidal air inflow from pulmonary blood flow [26] will result in poorer ventilation/perfusion matching and worse gas exchange than spontaneous ventilation. Furthermore, if the tidal breaths are too large, they will also impede venous return causing acute cor pulmonale and a decrease in cardiac output [19].
Right ventriculo-centric cardiovascular rules
- Central venous pressure is only elevated in disease Normally central venous pressure is zero or slightly higher than intrathoracic pressure
- If central venous pressure rises and remains elevated following a fluid challenge: STOP Make sure the patient is not slipping into acute cor pulmonale before proceeding
- For cardiac output to increase the RV must dilate There is a physical limit to which fluid resuscitation alone can increase cardiac output
- Right ventricular hypertrophy is essentially a deal with the devil: it is a losing proposition Increased filling must be associated with increased filling pressure limiting venous return and impairing LV diastolic compliance
DOI: 10.1007/s00134-014-3294-8
Also Check out
Additional New Information
More on EMCrit
- Right Ventricular failure(Opens in a new browser tab)
- Eight pearls for the crashing patient with massive PE(Opens in a new browser tab)
- Podcast 272 – Right Heart Failure with Sara Crager
- EMCrit 273 – Inhaled Pulmonary Vasodilators & Q&A with Sara Crager
- Podcast 143 – Hemodynamic Management of Massive Pulmonary Embolism (PE)
Additional Resources
You Need an EMCrit Membership to see this content. Login here if you already have one.
Professor
Nassau University Medical Center
No conflicts of interest (coi).
- EMCrit 363 – Retrograde Intubation - December 2, 2023
- ODR 013 – Should, Must, & Won't - November 25, 2023
- EMCrit Shadowboxing Case 6 – A Respiratory Case along with Extra Commentary from Mae West - November 23, 2023
Awesome review of a topic that, frankly, gets glossed over to a great degree in most EMS education resources! For those of us without access to POCUS, any thoughts on correlation between ECG signs such as RVH and pulmonary disease patterns to RV failure that might serve as guidance for treating these patients prehospital?
Fantastic and much-needed post. Several years ago I had a terrible experience intubating a young man on the heart-lung transplant list with severe pneumonia. We spent several hours trying to get him to stay alive on a ventilator and ultimately were unsuccessful. This case suggested two additional considerations when intubating the crashing pulmonary hypertension patient: (1) If you’re really worried the patient will die on the ventilator, might be worth preparing and/or starting inhaled epoprostenol or nitric acid via the ventilator immediately after intubation. This takes a bit of time to set up, so ideally should be ready to go… Read more »
Thank you for this awesome post. I am wondering what the optimal O2 target is for patients in acute RV failure who also happen to be chronic CO2 retainers. I recently had a patient with severe COPD and unrevascularized RCA disease who was admitted with a submassive PE, and was not a candidate for thrombolysis or intubation. She was hypotensive. I found it difficult to decide on a O2 target for her – balancing the risk of worsened V/Q mismatch/loss of hypoxic respiratory against the need to minimize RV afterload and maximize DO2 to the RV. I ended up going… Read more »
think you are in good shape >90%
Great interview with Dr. Wilcox about a subject that is poorly understood and treated. Fantastic!
Using hi flow oxygen would stave off intubation in many of these patients with hypoxic respiratory failure.
Wow, thanks for this post. Something that I don’t know enough about and will be definitely deep diving into!
Thank you Susan and Chris for writing absolutely the best article hitherto on PH and critically ill. It is a must read for anybody managing critically ill patients. Who should be screened- In my ED experience I screen everyone with SOB. I have had two surgical patients who I found had severe PH and my advice to my surgical colleagues was to not attempt to operate here and transfer to a tertiary center for management. Everybody with Systemic hypotension should be screened for pulmonary hypertension. Thus Hypertensive hypotension is a reality. My suggestion would be for colleagues doing echo to… Read more »
Such fantastic points! When I looked at the ketamine literature for other projects, I came across nothing regarding pulm vasoconstrict. If you find it again, send it my way.
I looked again and I have to say, I would go along with you, as recent papers seem to suggest no clinically significant increase in PVR with Ketamine.
I’m interested in your approach of loading with milrinone. In theory this would be more easily implemented than inhaled pulmonary vasodilators. If the load were given with noradrenaline to preserve your MAP – have you ever tried this or are you aware of any evidence for this approach?
Mark, most of my knowledge is through theory and fear. I have had the opportunity to manage three such patients and all did poorly. I have dealt with a few others, but in them Ceiling of care was discussed and felt appropriate not to be aggressive. I haven’t come across any evidence in the acute setting comparing the use of these vaspressor/inotrope/inodilator therapies.. There is some coming through from anesthetic literature perioperative. Inhaled milrinone is also getting good reviews. In short, I can’t say that I have a lot of expertise in managing this group of patients but my fear… Read more »
Hi! Greetings from Argentina! Amazing podcast! Recently used in my blog as refference. Look out this case:
https://interconsulta.online/caso-clinico-20-perdida-de-conciencia-y-cambios-en-ecg/
Excellent presentation