As you know, my motto is maximally aggressive care, ALWAYS! Maximally aggressive curative care and maximally aggressive palliative care. I did a podcast episode on critical care palliation a year or so ago.
At this year's EMCrit Conference, Ashley Shreves gave the ultimate lecture on the topic. Twenty minutes jam-packed with goodness.
- The End-of-Life and Palliation Education Resource Center
A listener, Don Zweig, wrote with this summary:
- We (as in ED docs) in general deal with End of Life Care and palliative care situations poorly.
- Our job as physician is to understand the family goals and values and then give a professional recommendation- it is not to give a menu–they have no medical knowledge to reasonably make this choice.
- Three things we should never say:
- “Do you want us to do everything?” Of course they do, but if you offer “everything” who wouldn't want mom to get everything? Could they say….”no, whatever you do , don't do everything for mom!” This also makes the family feel that everything (whatever that entails) is reasonable or possible. Instead use the ‘Pal Care' approach and say, “What would be most important to you and your mom now?” On the basis of what you hear make a reasoned professional recommendation.
- “Do you want us to resuscitate her?” This implies that we think it is possible or reasonable to do this! Since you ask this it must be reasonable. “You can just bring her back? Great, go ahead!” Use natural death language. So it sounds like your mom would want a natural death? When her heart stops we will not interfere with that process
- ” I am so sorry, there is nothing more we can do” There is a lot that can be done and it involves maximizing comfort and minimizing suffering. They need palliative care or hospice. So call a consult and give palliative meds.
- Try to get private room and take them off the monitor! There is no place for monitor in the dying patient for which you are providing comfort care.
- Treat discomfort with morphine or dilaudid in very small doses. Double every 15 minutes until decreased suffering.
Addendum
This amazing post on the blog Expensive Care is a must read on the topic of the ethics of CPR
Treating Pain in Palliative Patients
Need an Audio-Only version?
Right-Click here and choose save-as
Now on to the Vodcast…
Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 25:03 — 56.4MB) | Embed
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Android | Google Podcasts | Spotify | RSS | More
An ED Intensivist from NY. No conflicts of interest (coi).
Latest posts by Scott Weingart (see all)
- COVID19 – Awake Pronation (aka the Pig Roast) A guest write-up by David Gordon, MD - April 6, 2020
- EMCrit Wee – Webinar I Gave to Pulm/Crit Care Fellows on Avoiding Intubation and Initial Ventilation of COVID19 Patients - April 4, 2020
- EMCrit 269 – Rationing of Critical Care and Ventilators in COVID19 with Reub Strayer - March 31, 2020
Great podcast, Doc Weingart!
It’s reassuring for me to see that you deal with this topic on your blog: it confirms that we also, in Italy, are on a good way (we’re introducing these points in Italian EM by a formative initiative of Italian Society of EM). To deal with end of life is a mandatory competence for the EP.
I think that, in addition to what is reported by Shreves, we need to introduce some concepts like the right calculation of rescue dose for opiate-treated pts (particularly onco-pts), how to deal with opiate-induced adverse effects, and palliative sedation (that is often misinterpreted as euthanasia).
A little pearl: Buscopan (Joscine butil-bromure) for bronchial secretion in the terminal ill (but I’m not sure that it’s available in the USA).
These topics seem to be far from the field of EM but, as Shreves says very well, there are a lot of reasons for a terminal ill to seek for help in the ED!
Thank you,
Fabio De Iaco, Italy
Fabio,
great to hear from our Italian brethren. We use glycopyrrolate for the same purpose. We also have scopolamine patches.
Hey Scott, nice one!
DO you think AShley would be receptive to a PHARM podcast ? Palliative care is in fact one of my other clinical interests particularly in rural medicine.
Minh, also a great need to address this topic in the prehospital arena as well. Thanks for posting this for me to pass on to my paramedic students; sometimes their definition of “help” doesn’t fit with the patient’s!
Great Lecture !!
I will never use words like DNI/DNR for such patients…Natural Death is sounds better..
Thanks..
Another term that makes me cringe is “expire”..
absolutely, unless we are talking about exhalation. Even then it still sounds bad.
Brilliant,
I only wish I had seen this before my ICU fellowship a few years back…Although I don’t think I did a terrible job (got more thankful than angry family in EOL patient), this approach would have made my life so much easier…
I wish the ED folks that called me at the time as part of an institutionnal procedure to limit curative treatments in EOL situation had seen it to… And I’ll make damn sure that they watch it in the future.
Thanks again… and keep’em coming…
thanks, Nicolas
I have to say that this one of the best talks on the practice of Medicine I have ever had the honor of hearing.
In my practice, it took me a long time to realize that chronically ill people don’t need to have a terminal diagnosis to be dying. It took seeing the same pattern of increasing debilitation, the whole ECF/Hospital Merry-Go-Round, the entire spectrum when we go from functioning beings to bedridden shells of our former selves.
This talk lays it out in plain talk and emboldens us to BE A DAMN DOCTOR!, not just the piano player in the whorehouse that is medicine.
I so much enjoy the critical care podcasts you post here and my increasing ability to extend or save life because of the information I gain. But when all is said and done, we have to have the skill, mindset and courage to step up to the plate and say the family “If your mother could be with us now, what would she say?”
here, here
Great lecture on a truly important and timely topic…one of the best I’ve heard in my 25 years of practice as an EM doc… a game changer…thanks!
wow, now that is praise
When dealing with terminally ill patients and their families, in other than ED settings I do often encourage them to bring pictures and albums to the hospital… Quite a few times I’ve seen despair turn into celebration of life a given person lived. They start looking at the dying loved one through the beauty of all the memories they’ve made… Quite a metamorphosis I must say… In the ED, given time constraints I always try to talk to everyone involved and provide them as much privacy as possible, at the very least.
Awesome lecture! Thanks!
SUPERB lecture by Ashley Shreves (!) – on this tremendously important topic that is applicable (and to be recommended) far beyond the domain of the ED – to include virtually ALL medical providers (physicians plus non-physicians) – medical students – as well as selected families with a loved one nearing the process of dying (so that they too know what can be done for their loved ones).
On a related note – I’ll mention as potential supplemental material on this topic the excellent book by another full-time emergency physician (Dr. Monica Williams-Murphy) – The book is called, “It’s OK To Die” (http://www.oktodie.com/book ) – and can be recommended to health care providers as well as patients in the process of dying and their families.
CREDIT to Drs. Weingart, Shreves & Williams-Murphy for their combined important contributions to this previously not-well-covered area.
Great talk. As a resident I suspect the reason there is not much guidance given on this topic, is because of a lack of comfort and knowledge within our field. Thank you for this brief, high-yield talk.
[…] Palliative Care is a 25 minute presentation given by Dr Ashley Shreves at this years EMCrit […]
Scott,
Thank you so much for putting this up. I’m planning on playing this for the residency this year before my chief time ends, such a powerful talk with language that speaks to the humanism aspect, and gives such a more compassionate and meaningful way to speak with people and their families. Definitely a tool I will be using. Bravo Ashley Shreves, and thank you Scott.
Thanks Scott for putting up this lecture!! I always enjoy your podcast. Thanks for Don Zweig for doing the written summary! I have been making short Powerpoints so I can review later and this written summary helped a lot.
[…] Palliative Care is a 25 minute presentation given by Dr Ashley Shreves at this years EMCrit […]
Fantastic lecture! I would like to present this information to my fellow residents at Northwestern. Do you have the citation for the article she discussed at 19:00? Thanks.
Thanks for listening. There are several studies by Katri Clemens demonstrating the safety and efficacy of opiates at the end of life. The reference for the data I included in the talk is Clemens KE and Klaschik E. Effect of hydromorphone on ventilation in palliative care patients with dyspnea. Support Care Cancer 2008;16:93-99.
[…] Podcast 93 – Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves […]
[…] and palliative caring are INTENSIVE. Listen to Dr. Ashley Shreves on a EMCrit podcast if you’re not assured of this (actually, listen regardless; it’s value […]
[…] and palliative care are INTENSIVE. Listen to Dr. Ashley Shreves on the EMCrit podcast if you’re not convinced of this (actually, listen regardless; it’s worth […]
[…] 2. Emcrit Podcast 93: Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves […]
[…] spot is an absolute ripper on Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves – This is the best ED critical care palliative care lecture ever! Don’t believe me? […]
[…] others. For a greater introduction to palliative care in emergency medicine, be sure to listen to Dr. Ashley Shreeve’s EMCrit Conference talk and take a look at the Improving Palliative Care in Emergency Medicine (IPAL-EM) project […]
[…] Critical Care Palliation – Amazing Talk by Ashley Shreves on EMCRIT […]
[…] EMCrit podcast#93: Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves […]
[…] Critical Paliative Care (25 min) Ashley Shreevesová a její skv?lá p?ednáška o tom, jak komunikovat s rodinou umírajícího pacienta. Op?t skv?lé hlavn? pro mediky. […]
[…] Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves […]
[…] EMCrit Podcast 93 – Critical Care Palliation with Ashley Shreves […]
[…] Shreeves with very concrete advice on palliative care, the language used and therapies on […]